WORTHY
COUNSELING
NASHVILLE
Religious Trauma and LGBTQIA+ Therapy
in Nashville, TN and Online
Our Mission:
Worthy Counseling Center in Nashville, TN. specializes in religious trauma therapy, LGBTQIA+ affirming therapy, and persistent depression (dysthymia) or shame.
Whether you are navigating a shift in your faith, you have been ostracized by your church or family for your sexuality, or you’re experiencing a debilitating depression or shame that you just can’t seem to shake, we are here for you. Worthy Counseling Center is proud to be a safe and affirming space for the LGBTQIA+ and BIPOC communities.
Wherever and whoever you are, you are welcome.
Meet Tyler Nicodem, M.A.
Trauma Informed | Holistic Therapist | Former Pastor
Welcome to a transformative space where healing begins and personal growth takes root. I’m Tyler Nicodem, a mystic Christian therapist in Nashville, TN. with a passion for guiding individuals on their journey to holistic and spiritual well-being. I’m not like most Christian therapists in Nashville; I have had my own questioning, deconstruction, and reconstruction experience. I used to be certain of so many things — now I find solace and peace in not being certain, having wonder, and exploring the mystery of the Divine.
It’s painful to leave a faith you once loved…
It can feel disorienting — like you don’t know how to move forward, as if there’s a gaping hole inside you and nothing makes sense anymore. You might carry a deep fear that everything you believed in was a lie — that what once gave your life meaning might not have been real.
And yet… you’ve had moments you can’t explain.
Moments of great meaning, even holy — where you felt connected, close to God, or experienced what felt like divine intervention. You were once “on fire” for God, caught up in the passion and presence of faith.
But over time, that connection began to wane. You were taught it was because of you — that you were the problem. You prayed the right prayers, said the right words, went to church every Sunday, raised your hands in worship, took leadership roles, volunteered more… and yet, nothing.
No connection. Just silence. And you were told it was your fault, that some hidden sin was separating you from God.
Now your left trying to reconcile those sacred, unshakable moments with the pain, harm, or betrayal you experienced in your community of faith.
I’m here to walk alongside you through this process.
I help you find a new way forward — one that aligns with the person you’re becoming, even if it means leaving faith behind.
Together, we’ll explore different practices, traditions, and theologies, allowing you to discover paths that fit who you are truly created to be. Whether you’re reconnecting with faith or redefining it, this is a safe space for your journey.
“Pay attention to the things that bring a tear to your eye or a lump in your throat because they are signs that the holy is drawing near.”
— Frederick Buechner
Counseling Services In Nashville, TN.
Christian Counseling
You’re looking for someone who understands just how important your faith is to you; someone who intentionally integrates your spirituality into your healing. In the midst of so many therapists who are unwilling or are uncomfortable talking about faith, know that Tyler intentionally keeps faith at the center of your healing work.
Purity Culture Recovery
If you came of age in the 90s, 2000s, or 2010s, chances are you encountered purity culture. You might have been instructed to uphold “purity” as God’s mandate, perhaps even making pledges or wearing purity rings. Despite staying true to these ideals, you now grapple with shame and uncertainty regarding intimacy with your partner. Tyler is here to provide compassionate support as you navigate the complexities of your purity culture experiences.
LGBTQ
Affirming Therapy
Our LGBTQ-affirming therapy intertwines faith with compassion, offering a nurturing environment where spiritual and personal growth converge. Embrace authenticity and find solace in a journey towards self-acceptance, guided by a therapist who honors both your individuality and your beliefs.
Faith Deconstruction
Faith deconstruction is a unique and personal journey. A faith shift often brings a mix of emotions—from liberation to uncertainty. Therapy provides a safe harbor for you to navigate this emotional terrain, offering tools and insights to foster emotional well-being and resilience.
Ministry Burnout
As a former pastor in the church, Tyler understand the unique challenges that professional ministry brings. Whether you are at the end of your rope, been let go of your position for “moral failings,” or you feel tension with staff, congregants, or clergy, renewed hope can be found. With his expertise Tyler walks alongside you in the unique challenges you face in professional ministry.
Spiritual Trauma
Church is a haven for some, while for others it invokes pain. Church culture can deeply dismiss our basic emotional needs given to us by God. Church leaders may have taken advantage of you emotionally, spiritually, or sexually. You are not alone in your struggle; Tyler provides a safe space for you to find healing and hope from your church trauma.